Summer in the Buffalo-Niagara region is best enjoyed with a cold, creamy scoop of ice cream. Whether you’re a fan of classic soft serve, rich homemade custard, or adventurous gourmet flavors, Western New York has plenty of incredible ice cream spots to satisfy your sweet tooth. If you’re visiting the area and staying at Modern Farmhouse-716, be sure to check out these top ice cream shops!
1. Anderson’s Frozen Custard (Multiple Locations)
📍 Address: 2235 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14150 (and other locations)
🌐 Website: www.andersonscustard.com
A Buffalo institution since 1946, Anderson’s is famous for its creamy frozen custard and homemade hard ice cream. They also offer milkshakes, sundaes, and their signature custard-based shakes. Be sure to try their peanut butter and jelly sundae for a unique twist!
2. Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream (Lockport & Buffalo, NY)
📍 Address: 79 Canal St, Lockport, NY 14094
📍 Address: 1900 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14214
🌐 Website: www.lakeeffecticecream.com
Known for its creative flavors and locally inspired ingredients, Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream takes small-batch ice cream to the next level. With flavors like “Paula’s Glazed Donut” and “Loganberry,” they celebrate Buffalo’s unique food culture in every scoop.
3. Sweet Jennie’s (Clarence, NY)
📍 Address: 56 Main St, Clarence, NY 14031
🌐 Website: www.sweetjennies.com
Housed in the historic Old Red Mill, Sweet Jennie’s has been serving homemade ice cream for decades. Their rich and creamy selections include classic flavors and inventive seasonal options. The charming setting and friendly service make it a must-visit spot.
4. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee (Buffalo, NY)
📍 Address: 1501 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
🌐 Website: www.churnsoftserve.com
If you’re a soft-serve lover, Churn is a must-visit. This trendy ice cream shop offers unique toppings, house-made waffle cones, and an unbeatable espresso affogato. Their rotating flavors keep things exciting every time you visit.
5. Pautler’s Drive-In (Clarence, NY)
📍 Address: 6343 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051
🌐 Website: www.pautlersdrivein.com
A classic drive-in experience with a great selection of soft serve, sundaes, and shakes, Pautler’s is a nostalgic summer destination. After enjoying your ice cream, you can grab a burger or hot dog from their full menu.
6. King Condrell’s Candy & Ice Cream (Kenmore, NY)
📍 Address: 2805 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, NY 14217
🌐 Website: www.kingcondrells.com
A paradise for ice cream lovers and chocolate fans alike, King Condrell’s serves up massive sundaes, hand-dipped chocolates, and house-made fudge. Their famous “Kitchen Sink” sundae is a challenge worth trying if you’re visiting with a group!
7. Kone King (West Seneca, NY)
📍 Address: 865 Center Rd, West Seneca, NY 14224
🌐 Website: www.koneking.com
This local favorite specializes in creamy soft serve with dozens of toppings and flavor twists. Their classic chocolate-vanilla swirl and crunchy waffle cones make for a perfect summer treat.
8. Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream (Buffalo, NY)
📍 Address: 1488 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216
🌐 Website: www.hertelpoutineandcream.com
If you’re looking for something different, this ice cream spot pairs sweet and savory with a fun twist. You can grab a delicious sundae or float and pair it with their famous poutine!
Stay and Indulge at Modern Farmhouse-716
After a day of exploring Buffalo and satisfying your ice cream cravings, relax at Modern Farmhouse-716 in Getzville, NY. Our cozy and stylish Airbnb is conveniently located near many of these top dessert spots, making it easy to enjoy a sweet summer getaway.
Book Your Stay Today!
Plan your Buffalo-Niagara summer adventure now and stay at Modern Farmhouse-716 for a comfortable and relaxing experience. Check availability and book your stay at ModernFarmhouse716.com!
