Buffalo, NY, is home to some of the best chicken wings in the world, and if you’re visiting, trying authentic Buffalo wings is a must. Staying at Modern Farmhouse-716 puts you in a prime location to explore the top wing spots in the area. From the legendary Anchor Bar to the hidden gems known only to locals, here are 10 must-try places for wings while you’re in Buffalo.
1. Anchor Bar – The Birthplace of the Buffalo Wing
📍 1047 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14209
You can’t talk about Buffalo wings without Anchor Bar. As the birthplace of the Buffalo wing, they’ve been serving their classic crispy wings with buttery hot sauce since 1964. While some locals argue that better wings exist, it’s still a must-visit for wing lovers.
🔥 Must-Try: The Original Medium Wings – the recipe that started it all.
2. Duff’s Famous Wings – Where Spicy Means SPICY
📍 3651 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, NY 14226
Duff’s is Buffalo’s go-to spot for heat. Their wings are crispy, juicy, and heavily sauced, and their spice levels are no joke—medium at Duff’s is hot, and hot is VERY hot. If you like your wings extra saucy and packed with heat, this is the place for you.
🔥 Must-Try: Medium Wings (but be warned, they’re hotter than you think!).
3. Gabriel’s Gate – A Local Hidden Gem
📍 145 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201
Located in Buffalo’s historic Allentown district, Gabriel’s Gate serves up some of the city’s largest and crispiest wings. Their perfect balance of sauce, crispiness, and juicy meat has made them a fan favorite for years. Plus, the cozy pub vibe makes it a great place to grab a beer and enjoy a plate of wings.
🔥 Must-Try: Extra crispy hot wings with blue cheese.
4. Bar-Bill Tavern – Hand-Painted Wing Perfection
📍 185 Main St, East Aurora, NY 14052
If you don’t mind a short drive to East Aurora, Bar-Bill Tavern is 100% worth it. Each wing is hand-dipped in sauce, ensuring perfect coverage, and their Cajun honey butter BBQ wings are legendary. This is one of the top local picks for wings.
🔥 Must-Try: Cajun Honey Butter BBQ Wings.
5. Elmo’s Bar & Restaurant – Home of the Double-Dipped Wing
📍 2349 Millersport Hwy, Getzville, NY 14068
Located minutes from Modern Farmhouse-716, Elmo’s is famous for its double-dipped wings—fried, sauced, grilled, and sauced again. This method creates a smoky, caramelized flavor that makes their wings one-of-a-kind.
🔥 Must-Try: Cajun Honey Mustard Wings.
6. Wingnutz – The New King of Crunch
📍 700 Military Rd, Buffalo, NY 14216
A newer addition to Buffalo’s wing scene, Wingnutz is making a huge name for itself. Their extra-crispy, oversized wings are cooked perfectly and served in cast-iron skillets to keep them hot. Their homemade sauces set them apart from the rest.
🔥 Must-Try: Hot & Garlic Parmesan Wings.
7. Nine-Eleven Tavern – The Ultimate Hole-in-the-Wall Wings
📍 11 Bloomfield Ave, South Buffalo, NY 14220
If you want to eat where the locals eat, Nine-Eleven Tavern is a hidden gem in South Buffalo. The menu is simple, and the wings are coated in a rich, buttery, homemade hot sauce. It’s a no-frills, neighborhood bar with some of the best wings in town.
🔥 Must-Try: Medium Wings (their homemade sauce is elite).
8. Lenox Grill – A Hidden Wing Spot in a Historic Hotel
📍 140 North St, Buffalo, NY 14201
Lenox Grill is located inside the historic Lenox Hotel, and while it might not be the first place that comes to mind for wings, locals swear by them. Their wings are extra crispy, and they have some of the best sauce options in Buffalo.
🔥 Must-Try: Hot BBQ or Spicy Cajun Wings.
9. Gene McCarthy’s – Wings and Craft Beer Heaven
📍 73 Hamburg St, Buffalo, NY 14204
Gene McCarthy’s is an Irish pub meets craft brewery, making it a great spot for wings and a pint. Their wings are crispy, flavorful, and served with house-made sauces. Their Loganberry BBQ Wings offer a sweet-and-savory Buffalo twist.
🔥 Must-Try: Loganberry BBQ Wings.
10. Mammoser’s Tavern & Restaurant – A Southtowns Classic
📍 16 S Buffalo St, Hamburg, NY 14075
Mammoser’s is a bit off the beaten path in Hamburg, but their wings are some of the best outside of Buffalo proper. Known for their perfect crispiness and well-balanced sauces, they’re a favorite among locals looking for a classic wing experience.
🔥 Must-Try: Hot Garlic Wings.
Bonus Tip: Always Order Extra Blue Cheese!
One thing that makes Buffalo wings different from wings elsewhere? The blue cheese. Ranch is NOT the go-to here—every true Buffalo wing spot serves their wings with a side of thick, creamy blue cheese dressing (and celery sticks).
Stay at Modern Farmhouse-716 and Try Buffalo’s Best Wings
Buffalo is the chicken wing capital of the world, and these 10 restaurants are some of the best places to experience them. Whether you’re trying the original wings at Anchor Bar, spicy wings at Duff’s, or double-dipped wings at Elmo’s, you’re in for a treat.
📍 Staying at Modern Farmhouse-716? You’re just a short drive from these legendary wing spots while enjoying a stylish, comfortable home base in Getzville, NY.
➡️ Book your stay now at ModernFarmhouse716.com and start your Buffalo wing adventure today!
